Pakistan’s tax authority wants to take the face out of tax appeals. The Federal Board of Revenue has proposed a new system under which income tax disputes would be decided entirely online, with the officer hearing the case kept anonymous from the taxpayer from start to finish.
The proposal, set out in a draft notification issued on November 18, would add a new chapter to the Income Tax Rules, 2002, titled Faceless Appeals. The framework is still a draft and will only take effect once the Board issues a final notification, but its direction is unmistakable: fewer visits to tax offices, fewer personal encounters with officials, and a process run through screens rather than across desks.
Under the plan, a dedicated Appeals Wing made up of appellate units headed by Commissioners (Appeals) would take up eligible cases through the FBR’s electronic portal. The wing would work under the administrative control of the Member (Legal) for Inland Revenue, while keeping its independence in deciding appeals.
The most striking feature is anonymity. Cases would be assigned at random through an automated system, and neither the taxpayer nor the department would know which unit or commissioner was handling the matter. That anonymity would hold throughout the proceedings, including in the final order itself. Electronic orders would carry a Digital Identification Number instead of the deciding officer’s name or signature, so the decision would stand on its reasoning rather than on the identity of the person who wrote it.
The change would also end the need for taxpayers to appear in person. Evidence and arguments would be filed electronically, and hearings would take place through video conferencing or secure digital facilities. Taxpayers who prefer not to argue their case in a hearing at all could ask for a decision based on their written submissions alone.
The draft also builds in a safeguard against conflicts of interest. Any officer who was involved in the audit, assessment, quality control or original order in a case would be barred from deciding its appeal. Random allocation and the exclusion of officers connected to the original decision are meant to give the appeal a genuinely fresh look.
Not everything would change. Appeals already pending would stay with the commissioners now handling them, unless the Board itself transfers them into the new system. The right to go directly to the Appellate Tribunal under Section 127 of the Income Tax Ordinance would remain untouched, so taxpayers would keep the existing route beyond the first appeal. And where the electronic portal itself fails, the draft allows delays caused by a confirmed outage to be excused, recognising that a digital system is only fair if its own breakdowns do not punish the taxpayer.
The proposal is the latest step in a wider push by the FBR to run its work without face-to-face contact between taxpayers and officials. The Board has already introduced faceless systems for customs clearance and for assessments, and only two days before this draft appeared, President Asif Ali Zardari upheld a recommendation that the FBR operationalise a similar faceless regime for income tax refunds under Section 170A of the Income Tax Ordinance. That decision, in a case involving a refund claim of Rs42.86 million for tax year 2025, noted that refunds verified through the Board’s computerised system should be sanctioned and transferred electronically into taxpayers’ bank accounts without formal applications. The Islamabad High Court had earlier pushed in the same direction, directing an automated refund mechanism to cut down interaction with tax offices and speed up payments.
The draft amendments have been issued as SRO 2136(I)/2026 under Section 237 of the Income Tax Ordinance, 2001, and the FBR has invited objections and suggestions within three days of the draft’s publication in the official Gazette. The Board will then decide whether to notify the rules as they stand or adjust them in light of what comes back.
Whether the system works in practice will depend on things the draft cannot settle on paper. A faceless process is only as good as the portal behind it, and taxpayers in areas with unreliable connectivity will need the safeguards for portal failures to work as promised rather than as an afterthought. Hearings by video link will need to be genuinely accessible, not merely technically available, and the random allocation of cases will need to be demonstrably random if it is to earn trust. The promise, though, is a real one: a tax appeal decided on the papers, by an officer the taxpayer never meets and never needs to influence, with the decision traceable to a number rather than a name. If the FBR can deliver that, the most ordinary part of the proposal, that a taxpayer should be able to challenge a tax demand from home, may turn out to be its most important.
