A forensic expert has claimed that Jeffrey Epstein was killed in his prison cell, challenging the official finding that the disgraced financier took his own life. Professor Michael Freeman, a specialist in forensic medicine, says the injuries in Epstein’s autopsy photographs point to homicide by strangulation rather than suicide by hanging. He presented his analysis in London on Monday and spoke to BBC Newsnight.
Freeman spent a year examining autopsy records and photographs supplied by Epstein’s brother Mark, who has always said his brother was murdered. He says the work was independent and unpaid. With Itiel Dror and Anders Eriksson, he built three-dimensional computer models from Epstein’s measurements and the photographs, and argues they support his reading rather than the official account.
His doubts began with the ligature mark on Epstein’s neck. The medical examiner described a sloped mark typical of hanging, but Freeman says the photographs show a ragged, segmented pattern unlike the smooth noose recovered from the cell. He believes Epstein was strangled from behind with a narrow, knotted fabric ligature, then suspended from the bunk bed with the same material. He also pointed to what appear to be fingernail marks above the ligature mark, the victim’s attempt to pull the ligature away.
Freeman also identified other injuries pointing to an assault before death: a deep haemorrhage in Epstein’s left shoulder and marks on the face consistent with blows. The pattern, in his view, does not fit a man who hanged himself alone in a cell. “The injuries and the way the body was found don’t match up,” he said. “There’s only one remaining explanation then, and that is that the death was as a result of a homicide.”
The claim is striking, but its limits matter as much as its conclusions. Freeman never examined Epstein’s body; his assessment rests on photographs and documents from the autopsy, and his research has not undergone peer review. His paper was rejected by an academic journal and he plans to resubmit it. He has also said he has no idea who might have killed Epstein if he is right, because that question lies outside his investigation.
The New York City medical examiner’s office has not shifted its position. It told CNN it stands by its determination that Epstein died by suicide by hanging, and Dr Barbara Sampson, who carried out the 2019 autopsy, stands firmly behind that finding. Sampson told the Justice Department’s inspector general that the injuries were more consistent with hanging than strangulation, and that the defensive wounds expected in a strangulation victim were absent.
Epstein was found dead in his cell at the Metropolitan Correctional Center in Manhattan at around 6.30 on the morning of August 10, 2019, while awaiting trial on federal charges of sex trafficking minors. Arrested a month earlier, he had pleaded not guilty, and the autopsy the next day ruled the death a suicide. Doubt began almost at once. In 2019 the pathologist Michael Baden, hired by Mark Epstein to observe the autopsy, said fractures in Epstein’s neck pointed more towards strangulation than hanging.
Much of that doubt comes from the failures of the night he died. The two guards responsible for monitoring him allegedly slept during their shift, and surveillance failures stopped most nearby cameras recording, although live feeds remained available. Freeman adds that no photographs were taken of the body at the scene before it was removed, and the ligature was never preserved or examined. A Justice Department investigation later documented serious supervision failures, but found no evidence contradicting the FBI’s conclusion that no criminal act caused his death.
The claim arrives as the Epstein case returns to public discussion, with tens of thousands of pages of his files released. A New York Times review of those pages and his own notes found signs he intended to end his own life, which sits uneasily beside Freeman’s reading — a reminder that one expert’s interpretation cannot settle a case that has divided opinion for more than seven years.
What happens next is unclear. Freeman has published his findings with the medical examiner’s files, so other experts can test his argument, and peer review would give it a weight it does not yet carry. The medical examiner’s office has not answered his critique, and there is no sign of a fresh inquiry. For now the official record says suicide while a respected forensic specialist says murder, and the gap between them is filled by the questions that have surrounded the case since 2019: how a high-profile prisoner died unwatched, why the cameras failed, and why the basic evidence was never preserved.
The deeper lesson is that an official finding is only as credible as the investigation behind it. When guards sleep, cameras fail, a body is moved before it is photographed and a ligature is never examined, even a careful autopsy struggles to command public trust. Freeman’s claim may yet be tested and found wanting, but it has found a wide audience because of the failures that let people argue, seven years later, that nobody can be sure what happened in that cell.
