Former finance minister Miftah Ismail has warned that the price of atta in Pakistan could climb to Rs 200 per kilogram or more, accusing the federal government of financially destroying farmers over the past three years and calling its handling of the wheat crisis sheer incompetence.
In a post on X, the former minister said wheat is already selling at Rs 155 to Rs 157 per kilogram in Karachi’s open market. Farmers, he pointed out, sold the same wheat for less than Rs 65 per kilogram during the April to May harvest to stockists, government-selected investors and other middlemen, while imported wheat lands in Karachi at around Rs 95 per kilogram.
High Fertiliser Prices Behind Shortage
Miftah argued that the shortage began in the fields, long before the grain reached the market. He said the government kept urea and DAP fertiliser prices so high that farmers could not afford them in the quantities needed for a healthy crop, and the result is a shortage of perhaps three million tonnes of wheat.
The Punjab agriculture department has confirmed a decline in wheat production this year and a shortfall of two and a half million tonnes. Punjab produced nearly 22 million tonnes of wheat, but badly failed to meet its three million tonne procurement target, leaving the province short of the buffer stocks it has traditionally relied on.
A report by the United States Department of Agriculture, published in September, traced the problem to a fundamental change in wheat marketing policy. After IMF-aligned structural adjustments, Punjab altered its decades-old public procurement system and shifted buying to the private sector. With the state buying far less, farmers had to sell quickly at harvest, letting private buyers, middlemen and hoarders monopolise reserves with little transparency or regulation.
The figures in that report underline how fast the damage spread. Wheat flour prices rose 13 per cent in four months, from Rs 4,698 to Rs 5,300 per 40 kilograms, and by August 2026 they were about 60 per cent higher than a year earlier.
Late Imports Blamed
Miftah’s second charge was that the government waited too long, imported too little, and refused to let the private sector import at all, routing everything through the state-run Trading Corporation of Pakistan. Even after government imports of about a million tonnes, he said, a huge shortage remains.
The government has approved the import of up to one million tonnes of wheat this year, the first significant imports since 2024, and the Trading Corporation of Pakistan has opened a tender for 750,000 tonnes, in which nine international companies took part. Offers totalling 656,000 tonnes were received at about 349 to 370 dollars per tonne. Millers say it may stop prices climbing, but against daily grinding of around 70,000 tonnes, it will not bring them down.
The provinces, meanwhile, have asked for far more than the Centre is bringing in. Their combined demand stands at over 2.2 million tonnes: Punjab seeks one million tonnes, Sindh 720,000 tonnes including 500,000 through imports, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa 200,000 tonnes of imported wheat alongside 225,000 tonnes of local grain, and Balochistan 57,500 tonnes.
Miftah also warned the timing could create a second crisis. Wheat brought in late could arrive around February or March and crash the market just as the harvest begins in Sindh and Punjab, hurting farmers all over again. Therefore if the government decides to allow imports it should do so right away, he wrote.
Flour Prices Keep Climbing
For households, the crisis is already visible at the shop counter. Last week, Karachi retailers were selling No. 2.5 flour at Rs 180 per kilogram and fine flour at Rs 200 per kilogram, even as imported wheat continued to arrive.
Punjab has responded with a new pricing order. Under the Punjab Wheat Release and Flour Distribution Order 2026, issued on November 20, the release price of government wheat is fixed at Rs 4,500 per 40 kilograms and a 10 kilogram flour bag at Rs 1,275, up Rs 175 from Rs 1,100, nearly 16 per cent in one move. Digital monitoring and daily reporting are now mandatory, and mills caught hoarding or overcharging face severe penalties.
Even so, the open market is running well ahead of the official rates. Wheat is trading at Rs 5,900 a maund across Punjab, Rs 5,750 in Lahore and Rs 5,920 in Rawalpindi and Islamabad, while a 15 kilogram flour bag has reached Rs 2,500 wholesale in Lahore and Rs 2,650 in the twin cities. Flour millers have asked for an emergency import of 500,000 tonnes, warning prices will rise further if the governments do not act in time.
Cash-strapped consumers are already changing how they shop, buying flour in loose two kilogram quantities instead of five or ten kilogram bags, with a fine five kilogram bag now Rs 950 to Rs 1,000 and a ten kilogram bag close to Rs 2,000. Whether the Punjab order holds, and whether imports arrive before the harvest rather than on top of it, will decide if Miftah’s Rs 200 warning stays a warning or becomes the price households pay.
